Color, 1974, 100 mins.
Directed by Stelvio Massi
Starring Francis Matthews, Pascale Rivault, Howard Ross, Giorgio Albertazzi, Katia Christine, Catherine Diamant, Gabriella Lepori, Maria Cumani Quasimodo
Vinegar Syndrome (Blu-ray) (US R0 HD) / WS (2.35:1) (16:9)

A mere two years 5 Women for the Killerafter the tsunami of gialli that overwhelmed theaters in 1972, the distinctive 5 Women for the KillerItalian subgenre was already in a swift (temporary) decline by the time 5 Women for the Killer (5 donne per l'assassino) opened with a whimper and found few international takers. The groundbreakers like Mario Bava and Dario Argento seemed to have moved on by this point, and things were getting extra grubby with titles like this, The Killer Reserved Nine Seats, and Girl in Room 2A, as well as many obscurities that never made it outside of Italy at all. This one seemed poised to break out thanks to two big factors: the giallo directorial debut of Stelvio Massi, who had shot The Case of the Bloody Iris and was about to embark on his far more successful run of crime films (Emergency Squad, Destruction Force, Highway Racer, Convoy Busters, etc.), and an international lead in English actor Francis Matthews, a British TV vet and star of Hammer films like The Revenge of Frankenstein, Dracula, Prince of Darkness, and Rasputin the Mad Monk. On top of that the title is an obvious riff on Mario Bava's Sei donne per l'assassino (Six Women for the Killer), better known as Blood and Black Lace, a much bigger hit abroad than at home and arguably the most influential giallo of them all. Instead viewers got a rough, ragged thriller mixing crime procedure with surprisingly extreme imagery of nude murder victims with savage genital mutilation, going way beyond what was implied in What Have You Done to Solange? and paving the way for the grisly extremes yet to come later in later years like Massi's second and last giallo, 5 Women for the Killerthe 5 Women for the Killeroutrageously trashy Arabella: Black Angel.

After landing back home in Italy, reporter Giorgio Pisani (Matthews) is shattered to be informed right away that his pregnant wife has died in childbirth. Things take a turn when medical tests reveal that Giorgio is actually sterile, which means the baby couldn't possibly have bene his. Soon other pregnant women from the same medical facility as his wife are being attacked by a knife and hatchet-wielding maniac, with suspicion falling on Giorgio given his recent trauma. As the investigating detective (New York Ripper's Ross) deals with the rising body count (five women, of course), Giorgio rubs shoulders with other potential suspects like family doctor Lidia (The Beast's Rivault) and haughty Professor Betti (Last Year at Marienbad's Albertazzi).

Released just before the tide was about to turn with Deep Red, 5 Women for the Killer is an odd experience that trades in the familiar sleek, stylish look of its predecessors in favor of a more nervous, earthy visual scheme that uses the scope frame more for disorientation than aesthetic beauty. Matthews doesn't really have much to do or bring much to his role, but the storyline is a solid one with a wild double twist at the end that holds up to scrutiny. There's also an excellent score by jazz veteran Giorgio Gaslini, who was collaborating with Dario Argento around this time (on The Five Days and TV's Door into Darkness) and had already proven his giallo chops with So Sweet, So Dead. He and 5 Women for the KillerArgento would famously fall out right after this on Deep Red, but his contribution here is one of the film's strongest points 5 Women for the Killerand deserves an accessible soundtrack release someday beyond the scarce and wildly expensive Japanese releases.

One factor that hurt this film over the years is its sorry history on home video, namely a VHS clamshell release from Domovideo that hacked away five minutes of exposition, badly cropped and squeezed the film to fit 1.33:1 monitors, and added a few fleeting flashes of very unconvincing latex abdomens getting torn apart to some of the murder scenes. Massi's original version has apparently never been available in any form until the 2023 Blu-ray from Vinegar Syndrome, which restores the original running time and finally presents the scope framing in all its glory. It looks much better here than ever before with the new 4K scan from the 35mm interpositive wringing about as much color and detail as possible from the intentionally dark and dreary cinematography, and the DTS-HD MA Italian 2.0 mono track sounds excellent (with newly translated English subtitles). Incidentally, an English dub was evidently never prepared despite Matthews speaking his lines in English; virtually everyone else appears to be speaking Italian but is looped anyway as per the usual custom.

Given its relative obscurity, the film is decked out with a very robust slate of extras here that will also make you wonder how this one didn't end up in one of their Forgotten Gialli sets. We start off with a new audio commentary by Eugenio Ercolani and Troy 5 Women for the KillerHowarth covering all the bases here to help you appreciate the film including the backgrounds of all the actors, the state of the giallo at the time, multiple connections to New York Ripper, Massi's 5 Women for the Killerbackground in various capacities, and the traditions established within the giallo by this point. In "My Name Is Howard" (20m11s), Ross (a.k.a. Renato Rossini) looks back at the making of the film, his physically demanding upbringing that led to his strong physique, his stunt work that led to acting via Mario Bava, and his heyday in '70s and '80s film as a variety of strongmen and heavies. In "The Massi Touch" (24m57s), Danilo Massi (son and frequent collaborator of the director) recalls growing up watching his dad at work, the legendary sets he got to experience from Italy's golden era, the influence of Fernando Di Leo, the big impact Emergency Squad had on Stelvio's career, and the working approach that sometimes put him at odds with producers. "Working with Stelvio" (13m24s) features actor Luc Merenda reminiscing about his multiple projects with Massi, starting with The Last Round, as well as his thoughts on playing villains and various memories of the cigar-chomping auteur. In "Five Women for a Giallo" (21m42s), the always gregarious Luigi Cozzi lays out the landscape of the giallo after the turning point of Argento's animal trilogy, the impact wider international exposure had with American theaters proving receptive for a while, and the migration of genre-hopping directors like Massi to the giallo, as well as the impact of pivotal music scores like Gaslini's. Finally in "Cinematographers in Arms" (13m29s), Massi friend and fellow director/cinematographer Roberto Girometti looks at the trend of DOPs turning director at the time (also included names like Massimo Dallamano), the hierarchy of film sets in postwar Italy, the experiences of shooting other projects like newsreels, and his heroes like Marcello Gatti. Also included is a reel of those three fakey gore inserts from the VHS version (1m12s), which really aren't missed in the feature itself.

Reviewed on April 30, 2023.